Suggestions by @22shadow
4,442 suggestions
Muse (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
as Dexter kills them in one episode in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Benjamin Poindexter (Daredevil Series)
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Francis Dolarhyde (The Red Dragon)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Front Man (Hwang In-Ho)
as They Kill Dexter in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
William Afton (Five Nights At Freddy’s)
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Joker (Dark Knight Trilogy)
as They Kill Dexter in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Carmine Falcone
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Jason Voorhees
as They Kill Dexter in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Michael Myers
as They Kill Dexter in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Chucky (Charles Lee Ray)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Riddler (Matt Reeves)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Buffalo Bill (Jame Gumb)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Norman Bates
as Dexter kills them in one episode in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Oz Cobb (The Penguin)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Patrick Bateman
as Dexter kills them easily in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Wilson fisk/Kingpin (marvel cinematic universe)
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Anton Chigurh
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
John Kramer (Saw)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Nathan Fillion
as Green Lantern in Man of Tomorrow (2027)
Edi Gathegi
as Mr. Terrific in Man of Tomorrow (2027)