Suggestions by @22shadow
4,411 suggestions
John Wick
as They Kill Dexter in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Dollface (The Strangers)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Pin-Up Girl (The Strangers)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Man in the Mask / Scarecrow (The Strangers)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
John Doe (Se7en)
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
The Fisherman / Ben Willis
as Dexter kills them in one episode in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Annie Wilkes
as Dexter kills them in one episode in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Billy Magnussen
as Midnight Mangler in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Tramell Tillman
as JawSplitter in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Jesse Plemons
as The Sleepy Eyed Strangler in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
John Leguizamo
as The Yonkers Slayer in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Mason Verger
as Dexters wins with some effort in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Leatherface
as Unlikely but Dexter could win in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
Jack Torrance
as Dexter kills them in one episode in Dexter Morgan vs Fictional Killers
James Remar
as Harry Morgan in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
as Don Framt in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Eric Stonestreet
as Albert "Al" Walker in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
C. S. Lee
as Vince Maskua in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Desmond Harrington
as Captain Joey Quinn in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)
Emily Kimball
as Gigi Jones in Dexter: Resurrection (Season 2)