Suggestions by @1034905

Willem Dafoe

as Anti-Cosmo in The Fairly OddParents Movie

Score: +1

Will Arnett

as Cookie the Ogre in Shrek (Live action)

Score: +1

Elizabeth Banks

as Gretched the Ogre in Shrek (Live action)

Score: +1

Steve Burns

as Cookie the Ogre in Shrek (Live action)

Score: -1

Chris Evans

as Brogan the Ogre in Shrek (Live action)

Score: +1

Will Ferrell

as Rumpelstiltskin in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Maya Rudolph

as Gretched in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Steve Burns

as Cookie in Shrek (Live Action)

Score: +1

Chris Evans

as Brogan in Shrek (Live Action)

Score: +2

Chris Evert

as Brogan in Shrek (Live Action)

Score: 0

Chris Hemsworth

as Shrek in Shrek (Live Action)

Score: -2

Steve Burns

as Cookie in Shrek

Score: 0

Chris Evans

as Brogan in Shrek

Score: +3

Steve Burns

as Gretched in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: -1

Will Arnett

as Cookie in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Chris Evans

as Brogan in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Tara Strong

as Pinocchio in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Dee Bradley Baker

as Wolf in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Cathy Weseluck

as Gingy in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1

Billy Crystal

as Puss In Boots in Shrek 4 (2030)

Score: +1