Fan Casting YouTube Monsters
Who Should Play Them?
by Richman
Story added by richman on June 17, 2025
Story Plot
Casting some of YouTube’s darkest personalities, if they were to ever receive biopics…
This story does not allow roles to be added.
Fan Casting Roles for YouTube Monsters
-
Elliot Rodger
Top suggestion out of 8
Louis Partridge
Cast Your Vote -
Trey Sesler (Mr. Anime)
Top suggestion out of 10
Max Charles
Cast Your Vote -
Randy Stair (Andrew Blaze)
Top suggestion out of 10
Nathanael Saleh
Cast Your Vote -
Jared Lee Loughner
Top suggestion out of 9
Austin Butler
Cast Your Vote -
Samantha Wohlford
Top suggestion out of 10
Katherine McNamara
Cast Your Vote -
Pekka-Eric Auvinen
Top suggestion out of 9
Louis Hofmann
Cast Your Vote -
Alyssa Dayvault
Top suggestion out of 10
Cristin Milioti
Cast Your Vote -
Anthony Powell
Top suggestion out of 15
A.J. Beckles
Cast Your Vote -
Stephen McCullagh
Top suggestion out of 9
Brandon Flynn
Cast Your Vote -
Jake Davison
Top suggestion out of 10
Cooper Hoffman
Cast Your Vote -
Austin Jones
Top suggestion out of 10
Rudy Pankow
Cast Your Vote -
Ruby Franke
Top suggestion out of 7
Jodie Comer
Cast Your Vote -
Luka Magnotta
Top suggestion out of 9
Cameron Monaghan
Cast Your Vote -
Bryant Turhan Emmerson Moreland (EDP445)
Top suggestion out of 10
Brian Tyree Henry
Cast Your Vote -
Jason Matthew Ethier (ImJayStation)
Top suggestion out of 8
Michael Cera
Cast Your Vote -
Vitaly Zdorovetskiy (Vitalyzdtv)
Top suggestion out of 8
Alfie Allen
Cast Your Vote -
Ian Rylett
Top suggestion out of 8
Tim Roth
Cast Your Vote
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Need an account?
Create a free account
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Join the Conversation