![Recasting the Oscars [2019] Fan Casting Poster](http://assets.mycast.io/posters/recasting-the-oscars-2019-fan-casting-poster-562600-medium.jpg?1743508245)
Fan Casting Recasting the Oscars [2019]
Story added by alabasteri on April 1, 2025
Story Plot
Alternate choices.
Contribute
Fan Casting Roles for Recasting the Oscars [2019]
-
Arthur Fleck/Joker (Joaquin Phoenix)
![Adrien Brody as Arthur Fleck/Joker in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-adrien-brody-1030743_large.jpg?1711213938)
Top suggestion out of 7
Adrien Brody
Cast Your Vote -
Judy Garland (Renee Zellweger)
![Winona Ryder as Judy Garland in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-winona-ryder-910983_large.jpg?1699415102)
Top suggestion out of 2
Winona Ryder
Cast Your Vote -
Cliff Booth (Brad Pitt)
![Timothy Olyphant as Cliff Booth in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-timothy-olyphant-201958_large.jpg?1618795404)
Top suggestion out of 4
Timothy Olyphant
Cast Your Vote -
Nora Fanshaw (Laura Dern)
![Melora Hardin as Nora Fanshaw in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-melora-hardin-1344410_large.jpg?1743525549)
Top suggestion out of 4
Melora Hardin
Cast Your Vote -
Salvador Mallo (Antonio Banderas)
![Benicio del Toro as Salvador Mallo in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-benicio-del-toro-401008_large.jpg?1649318465)
Top suggestion out of 3
Benicio del Toro
Cast Your Vote -
Rick Dalton (Leonardo DiCaprio)
![Joaquin Phoenix as Rick Dalton in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-joaquin-phoenix-1098580_large.jpg?1718458697)
Top suggestion out of 5
Joaquin Phoenix
Cast Your Vote -
Charlie Barber (Adam Driver)
![Andrew Garfield as Charlie Barber in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-andrew-garfield-650651_large.jpg?1673433543)
Top suggestion out of 5
Andrew Garfield
Cast Your Vote -
Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio (Jonathan Pryce)
![Jeremy Irons as Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-jeremy-irons-925549_large.jpg?1700915663)
Top suggestion out of 4
Jeremy Irons
Cast Your Vote -
Harriet Tubman (Cynthia Erivo)
![Issa Rae as Harriet Tubman in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-issa-rae-348718_large.jpg?1642637982)
Top suggestion out of 2
Issa Rae
Cast Your Vote -
Rosie Betzler (Scarlett Johansson)
![Natalie Portman as Rosie Betzler in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-natalie-portman-1051354_large.jpg?1713327134)
Top suggestion out of 4
Natalie Portman
Cast Your Vote -
Josephine ''Jo'' March (Saoirse Ronan)
![Lucy Boynton as Josephine ''Jo'' March in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-lucy-boynton-994198_large.jpg?1707826143)
Top suggestion out of 7
Lucy Boynton
Cast Your Vote -
Megyn Kelly (Charlize Theron)
![Kate Winslet as Megyn Kelly in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-kate-winslet-946016_large.jpg?1703098703)
Top suggestion out of 3
Kate Winslet
Cast Your Vote -
Fred Rogers (Tom Hanks)
![Dennis Quaid as Fred Rogers in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-dennis-quaid-842637_large.jpg?1692207779)
Top suggestion out of 2
Dennis Quaid
Cast Your Vote -
Pope Benedict XVI (Anthony Hopkins)
![Michael Caine as Pope Benedict XVI in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-michael-caine-1344560_large.jpg?1743534473)
Top suggestion out of 3
Michael Caine
Cast Your Vote -
Jimmy Hoffa (Al Pacino)
![Christopher Walken as Jimmy Hoffa in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-christopher-walken-661986_large.jpg?1674494991)
Top suggestion out of 3
Christopher Walken
Cast Your Vote -
Russell Bufalino (Al Pacino)
![Danny DeVito as Russell Bufalino in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-danny-devito-416949_large.jpg?1651236143)
Top suggestion out of 2
Danny DeVito
Cast Your Vote -
Barbara ''Bobi'' Jewell (Kathy Bates)
![Glenn Close as Barbara ''Bobi'' Jewell in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-glenn-close-1193946_large.jpg?1727457808)
Top suggestion out of 2
Glenn Close
Cast Your Vote -
Nicole Barber (Scarlett Johansson)
![Amanda Seyfried as Nicole Barber in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-amanda-seyfried-904618_large.jpg?1698844149)
Top suggestion out of 3
Amanda Seyfried
Cast Your Vote -
Amy March (Florence Pugh)
![Milly Alcock as Amy March in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-milly-alcock-775166_large.jpg?1685148706)
Top suggestion out of 4
Milly Alcock
Cast Your Vote -
Kayla Pospisil (Margot Robbie)
![Dakota Johnson as Kayla Pospisil in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](//assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-dakota-johnson-927933_large.jpg?1701183125)
Top suggestion out of 3
Dakota Johnson
Cast Your Vote
![Adrien Brody as Arthur Fleck/Joker in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-adrien-brody-1030743_large.jpg?1711213938)
![Winona Ryder as Judy Garland in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-winona-ryder-910983_large.jpg?1699415102)
![Timothy Olyphant as Cliff Booth in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-timothy-olyphant-201958_large.jpg?1618795404)
![Melora Hardin as Nora Fanshaw in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-melora-hardin-1344410_large.jpg?1743525549)
![Benicio del Toro as Salvador Mallo in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-benicio-del-toro-401008_large.jpg?1649318465)
![Joaquin Phoenix as Rick Dalton in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-joaquin-phoenix-1098580_large.jpg?1718458697)
![Andrew Garfield as Charlie Barber in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-andrew-garfield-650651_large.jpg?1673433543)
![Jeremy Irons as Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-jeremy-irons-925549_large.jpg?1700915663)
![Issa Rae as Harriet Tubman in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-issa-rae-348718_large.jpg?1642637982)
![Natalie Portman as Rosie Betzler in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-natalie-portman-1051354_large.jpg?1713327134)
![Lucy Boynton as Josephine ''Jo'' March in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-lucy-boynton-994198_large.jpg?1707826143)
![Kate Winslet as Megyn Kelly in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-kate-winslet-946016_large.jpg?1703098703)
![Dennis Quaid as Fred Rogers in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-dennis-quaid-842637_large.jpg?1692207779)
![Michael Caine as Pope Benedict XVI in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-michael-caine-1344560_large.jpg?1743534473)
![Christopher Walken as Jimmy Hoffa in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-christopher-walken-661986_large.jpg?1674494991)
![Danny DeVito as Russell Bufalino in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-danny-devito-416949_large.jpg?1651236143)
![Glenn Close as Barbara ''Bobi'' Jewell in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-glenn-close-1193946_large.jpg?1727457808)
![Amanda Seyfried as Nicole Barber in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-amanda-seyfried-904618_large.jpg?1698844149)
![Milly Alcock as Amy March in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-milly-alcock-775166_large.jpg?1685148706)
![Dakota Johnson as Kayla Pospisil in Recasting the Oscars [2019]](http://assets.mycast.io/actor_images/actor-dakota-johnson-927933_large.jpg?1701183125)
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Need an account?
Create a free account
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Join the Conversation