Fan Casting Aly Michalka as Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill

kkaayyy made this fan casting suggestion on November 8, 2021. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Aly Michalka as Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill

Aly Michalka

35 years old

Alyson Renae Michalka (born March 25, 1989) is an American actress, singer, musician, and model. She rose to prominence with her starring role as Keely Teslow in the Disney Channel sitcom Phil of t...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill

add character image

Fan Casting

Aly Michalka

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill

recast

Half-brothers Lucas and Nathan Scott trade between kinship and rivalry both on the basketball court and in the hearts of their friends in the small, but not so quiet town of Tree Hill, North Carolina.

See Story

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Aly Michalka as Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill

Aly Michalka is known for her roles in Easy A, Grown Ups 2, and Bandslam. She has been suggested by fans for 260 roles on myCast, including Female Musical Artists. in The Most Attractive Celebrities. Similar actors include Hayden Panettiere, Hilary Duff, and AJ Michalka. Aly Michalka was suggested to play Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill by kkaayyy. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Samara Weaving, Kathryn Newton, and Peyton List. One Tree Hill has 59 roles, including Haley James Scott, Brooke Davis Baker, and Jake Jaglieski.

Supporters (5)

Opposers (2)

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott in One Tree Hill

Emma Mackey

Emma Mackey

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

6 Vote Yes

4 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Lili Reinhart

Lili Reinhart

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

6 Vote Yes

5 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Elizabeth Gillies

Elizabeth Gillies

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

3 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Penelope Mitchell

Penelope Mitchell

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

3 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Olivia Holt

Olivia Holt

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

3 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Hayley Law

Hayley Law

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

3 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Giorgia Whigham

Giorgia Whigham

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

2 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

One Tree Hill
Sabrina Carpenter

Sabrina Carpenter

as

Peyton Sawyer/Peyton Scott

in

One Tree Hill

2 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

One Tree Hill

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More