Fan Casting Jaws: Resurface (1999)

24 years after several Amity Beach residents were killed by a killer shark, a newly-widowed Michael Brody (George Clooney), takes his daughters Annie and Elsie (Kirsten Dunst and Mischa Barton), to move in with his parents Martin and Ellen Brody (Roy Scheider and Lorraine Gary). But after a shark attack interrupts the peaceful town for the first time in years, Michael forbids his daughters from going in the ocean. Little does he know, Annie plans on taking a boat out with new friends to a nearby island. With help from his father and younger brother Sean (Brad Pitt), Michael hunts down a new killer shark to save his daughter and her friends. This film would as a direct sequel to the original 1975 film, ignoring past sequels.