Fan Casting Craig Sheffer as Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

chris83 made this fan casting suggestion on March 8, 2022. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Craig Sheffer as Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Craig Sheffer

64 years old

Craig Sheffer is an American actor. He is known for the role of Keith Scott on One Tree Hill.

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

add character image

Fan Casting

Craig Sheffer

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Twenty years earlier

by CBS

A father recounts to his children - through a series of flashbacks - the journey he and his four best friends took leading up to him meeting their mother.

See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Craig Sheffer as Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Craig Sheffer is known for his roles in A River Runs Through It, Stand Up Guys, and Nightbreed. He has been suggested by fans for 51 roles on myCast, including One Tree Hill in Best Actors and Actres in Series. Similar actors include Johnny Depp, Tom Cruise, and Keanu Reeves. Craig Sheffer was suggested to play Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994) by chris83. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Jeff Goldblum, John Travolta, and Ray Liotta. How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994) has 51 roles, including Carly Whittaker, Heather Mosby, and Katie Scherbatsky.

Supporters (1)

chris83

Opposers (0)

Nobody opposes this suggestion yet.

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Punchy in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Peter Gallagher

Peter Gallagher

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

4 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Ray Romano

Ray Romano

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Andy García

Andy García

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Robby Benson

Robby Benson

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Chris Noth

Chris Noth

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
John Murray

John Murray

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Adrian Zmed

Adrian Zmed

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Tony Danza

Tony Danza

as

Punchy (Adam Punciarello)

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More