• Home
  • Stories
  • People
  • Fan Casting Community
  • Add a Story
  • Register/Login
myCast logo that links to fan casting home page
  • Stories
  • People
  • Fan Casting Community
  • Sign Up / Login
Menu
How I Met Your Mother Fan Casting Poster
Add to myCast Favorites Mark as watched

Fan Casting How I Met Your Mother

Story added by jcorlett21 on August 16, 2023

Story Plot

Recast of How I Met Your Mother

This story does not allow roles to be added.

How I Met Your Mother Sitcom Recast

Fan Casting Roles for How I Met Your Mother

  • Ted Mosby
    Paul Rudd as Ted Mosby in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Paul Rudd

    Cast Your Vote
  • Robin Scherbatsky
    Evangeline Lilly as Robin Scherbatsky in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Evangeline Lilly

    Cast Your Vote
  • Marshall Eriksen
    Brendan Fraser as Marshall Eriksen in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Brendan Fraser

    Cast Your Vote
  • Lily Aldrin
    Julie Bowen as Lily Aldrin in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Julie Bowen

    Cast Your Vote
  • Barney Stinson
    Seann William Scott as Barney Stinson in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Seann William Scott

    Cast Your Vote
  • Tracy McConnell
    Linda Cardellini as Tracy McConnell in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Linda Cardellini

    Cast Your Vote
  • Ranjit
    Harish Patel as Ranjit in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Harish Patel

    Cast Your Vote
  • James Stinson
    Marlon Wayans as James Stinson in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Marlon Wayans

    Cast Your Vote
  • Victoria
    Rachel McAdams as Victoria in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Rachel McAdams

    Cast Your Vote
  • Quinn Garvey
    Malin Åkerman as Quinn Garvey in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Malin Åkerman

    Cast Your Vote
  • Carl the Bartender
    Jay Hernandez as Carl the Bartender in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Jay Hernandez

    Cast Your Vote
  • Zoey Pierson
    Mena Suvari as Zoey Pierson in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Mena Suvari

    Cast Your Vote
  • Randy Wharmpess
    Bill Hader as Randy Wharmpess in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Bill Hader

    Cast Your Vote
  • Rachel
    Jill Wagner as Rachel in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Jill Wagner

    Cast Your Vote
  • Jerome Whittaker
    Jeffrey Tambor as Jerome Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Jeffrey Tambor

    Cast Your Vote
  • Trudy
    Eva Longoria as Trudy in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Eva Longoria

    Cast Your Vote
  • Scooter
    Johnny Galecki as Scooter in How I Met Your Mother
    Top suggestion

    Johnny Galecki

    Cast Your Vote
 

Join the Conversation

Submit
Comments (0)
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Fan Casts
  • Fan Casting Topics
  • Talent
  • Fan Casting Community
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Powered by TMDB
myCast

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!

Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:

  • Add your own stories and characters
  • Make casting suggestions
  • Vote and comment on casting suggestions
  • Add and edit talent profiles
  • Post to the forums
Need an account?
Create a free account

Login to myCast

Login with Facebook

or

  • Forgot your password?
  • Create a free account
myCast

Join myCast

Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!

Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:

  • Add your own stories and characters
  • Make casting suggestions
  • Vote and comment on casting suggestions
  • Add and edit talent profiles
  • Post to the forums
Already have an account?
Login to an existing account

Register for myCast

Login with Facebook

or

  • Forgot your password?
  • Login to an existing account