Fan Casting April Fool's Day (2006)

When a group of college students decides to spend spring break at the secluded island estate of their wealthy classmate, Muffy St. John (Rebecca Hall), what starts out as a fun, hedonistic weekend turns into something more sinister. Muffy is very fond of practical jokes, and sets up numerous gags throughout her mansion. But, when friends begin going missing and turn up dead, they realize that they're trapped on the isolated isle with a mysterious and brutal killer.