Browse Casting Suggestions by pauldmckay on myCast - Fan Casting Your Favorite Stories

Recent fan casting activity by pauldmckay

Kevin Kline

Kevin Kline

as

Treebeard

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Judi Dench

Judi Dench

as

Arwen

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jeff Goldblum

Jeff Goldblum

as

Mouth of Sauron

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Shia LaBeouf

Shia LaBeouf

as

Eomer

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Paul Giamatti

Paul Giamatti

as

Elrond

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Matt Berry

Matt Berry

as

Theoden

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Eric André

Eric André

as

Grima Wormtongue

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joey Diaz

Joey Diaz

as

King of the Dead

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jay Baruchel

Jay Baruchel

as

Lurtz

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
David Spade

David Spade

as

Haldir of Lorien

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Owen Wilson

Owen Wilson

as

Mouth of Sauron

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jonah Hill

Jonah Hill

as

Grima Wormtongue

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Pauly Shore

Pauly Shore

as

Isildur

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Conan O'Brien

Conan O'Brien

as

Treebeard

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Wayne Brady

Wayne Brady

as

Sauron

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Timothy Olyphant

Timothy Olyphant

as

All of the Oliphants

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Tom Kenny

Tom Kenny

as

Witch-King of Angmar

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Zach Galifianakis

Zach Galifianakis

as

Theoden

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Dave Franco

Dave Franco

as

Faramir

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
James Franco

James Franco

as

Boromir

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Graham Norton

Graham Norton

as

Saruman

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Neil Patrick Harris

Neil Patrick Harris

as

Elrond

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Dick Van Dyke

Dick Van Dyke

as

Gandalf

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jenna Ortega

Jenna Ortega

as

Arwen

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Pete Davidson

Pete Davidson

as

Gollum

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jeremy Clarkson

Jeremy Clarkson

as

Bilbo

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Kurt Russell

Kurt Russell

as

Eomer

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
The Great Khali

The Great Khali

as

Legolas

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Chris Pontius

Chris Pontius

as

Merry

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Steve-O

Steve-O

as

Pippin

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Matt Damon

Matt Damon

as

Theoden

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joe Rogan

Joe Rogan

as

Gimli

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Joe Rogan

Joe Rogan

as

Theoden

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Russell Brand

Russell Brand

as

Denethor

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Paul Rudd

Paul Rudd

as

Sam

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Harrison Ford

Harrison Ford

as

Witch-King of Angmar

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

0 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
John Cena

John Cena

as

Aragorn

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Jennifer Coolidge

Jennifer Coolidge

as

Galadriel

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Goldie Hawn

Goldie Hawn

as

Eowyn

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast
Aziz Ansari

Aziz Ansari

as

Frodo

in

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Kevin Kline

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Judi Dench

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Jeff Goldblum

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Shia LaBeouf

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Paul Giamatti

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Matt Berry

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Eric André

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Joey Diaz

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Jay Baruchel

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

David Spade

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Owen Wilson

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Jonah Hill

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Pauly Shore

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Conan O'Brien

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Wayne Brady

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Timothy Olyphant

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Tom Kenny

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Zach Galifianakis

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Dave Franco

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

James Franco

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Graham Norton

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Neil Patrick Harris

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Dick Van Dyke

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Jenna Ortega

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Pete Davidson

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Jeremy Clarkson

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Kurt Russell

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

The Great Khali

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Chris Pontius

Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

Steve-O