Casting Suggestions by pauldmckay

• 

  Kevin Kline

  Kevin Kline

  as

  Treebeard

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Judi Dench

  Judi Dench

  as

  Arwen

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Jeff Goldblum

  Jeff Goldblum

  as

  Mouth of Sauron

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Shia LaBeouf

  Shia LaBeouf

  as

  Eomer

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Paul Giamatti

  Paul Giamatti

  as

  Elrond

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Matt Berry

  Matt Berry

  as

  Theoden

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Eric André

  Eric André

  as

  Grima Wormtongue

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Joey Diaz

  Joey Diaz

  as

  King of the Dead

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Jay Baruchel

  Jay Baruchel

  as

  Lurtz

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  David Spade

  David Spade

  as

  Haldir of Lorien

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Owen Wilson

  Owen Wilson

  as

  Mouth of Sauron

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  0 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Jonah Hill

  Jonah Hill

  as

  Grima Wormtongue

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  0 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Pauly Shore

  Pauly Shore

  as

  Isildur

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Conan O'Brien

  Conan O'Brien

  as

  Treebeard

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  0 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Wayne Brady

  Wayne Brady

  as

  Sauron

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

• 

  Timothy Olyphant

  Timothy Olyphant

  as

  All of the Oliphants

  in

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Paul's Terrible LOTR Fancast