Casting Suggestions by shuerk

• 

  Lucy Boynton

  Lucy Boynton

  as

  Bonnie MacFarlane

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  10 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Bonnie MacFarlane

• 

  Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje

  Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje

  as

  Hercule Fontaine

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  11 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Hercule Fontaine

• 

  Lucy Boynton

  Lucy Boynton

  as

  Penelope Braithwaite

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  17 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Penelope Braithwaite

• 

  Bob Odenkirk

  Bob Odenkirk

  as

  Josiah Trelawny

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  13 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Josiah Trelawny

• 

  Ella Hughes

  Ella Hughes

  as

  Mary-Beth Gaskill

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  10 Vote Yes

  6 Vote No

  

  Mary-Beth Gaskill

• 

  Ella Hughes

  Ella Hughes

  as

  Molly O'Shea

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  13 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Molly O'Shea

• 

  Luke Roessler

  Luke Roessler

  as

  Jack Marston (boy)

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  15 Vote Yes

  6 Vote No

  

  Jack Marston (boy)

• 

  Graham McTavish

  Graham McTavish

  as

  Bill Williamson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  7 Vote Yes

  13 Vote No

  

  Bill Williamson

• 

  Gerard Butler

  Gerard Butler

  as

  Arthur Morgan

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  7 Vote Yes

  16 Vote No

  

  Arthur Morgan

• 

  Iwan Rheon

  Iwan Rheon

  as

  Kieran Duffy

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  13 Vote Yes

  3 Vote No

  

  Kieran Duffy

• 

  Aidan Turner

  Aidan Turner

  as

  Kieran Duffy

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  6 Vote Yes

  7 Vote No

  

  Kieran Duffy

• 

  Aaron Taylor-Johnson

  Aaron Taylor-Johnson

  as

  Sean MacGuire

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  4 Vote Yes

  9 Vote No

  

  Sean MacGuire

• 

  Evan Peters

  Evan Peters

  as

  Sean MacGuire

  in

  Red Dead Redemption.

  20 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Sean MacGuire