Casting Suggestions by shanekavanagh

• 

  Jessie T. Usher

  Jessie T. Usher

  as

  Lenny Summers

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  11 Vote Yes

  13 Vote No

  

  Lenny Summers

• 

  John C. Reilly

  John C. Reilly

  as

  Mr. Gillis

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  5 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Mr. Gillis

• 

  Kurt Russell

  Kurt Russell

  as

  Colonel Favours

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  11 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Colonel Favours

• 

  John Goodman

  John Goodman

  as

  Leviticus Cornwall

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  14 Vote Yes

  8 Vote No

  

  Leviticus Cornwall

• 

  Natalie Dormer

  Natalie Dormer

  as

  Penelope Braithwaite

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  10 Vote Yes

  9 Vote No

  

  Penelope Braithwaite

• 

  Rose Leslie

  Rose Leslie

  as

  Molly O'Shea

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  44 Vote Yes

  16 Vote No

  

  Molly O'Shea

• 

  Kathy Bates

  Kathy Bates

  as

  Catherine Braithwaite

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  15 Vote Yes

  5 Vote No

  

  Catherine Braithwaite

• 

  Taylor Lautner

  Taylor Lautner

  as

  Eagle Flies

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  4 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Eagle Flies

• 

  Helena Bonham Carter

  Helena Bonham Carter

  as

  Susan Grimshaw

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  90 Vote Yes

  29 Vote No

  

  Susan Grimshaw

• 

  Liev Schreiber

  Liev Schreiber

  as

  Bill Williamson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  19 Vote Yes

  15 Vote No

  

  Bill Williamson

• 

  Eka Darville

  Eka Darville

  as

  Charles Smith

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  2 Vote Yes

  18 Vote No

  

  Charles Smith

• 

  Alfie Allen

  Alfie Allen

  as

  Sean MacGuire

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  39 Vote Yes

  23 Vote No

  

  Sean MacGuire

• 

  Letitia Wright

  Letitia Wright

  as

  Tilly Jackson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  75 Vote Yes

  17 Vote No

  

  Tilly Jackson

• 

  David Harbour

  David Harbour

  as

  Bill Williamson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  198 Vote Yes

  16 Vote No

  

  Bill Williamson

• 

  Boyd Holbrook

  Boyd Holbrook

  as

  Micah Bell

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  32 Vote Yes

  28 Vote No

  

  Micah Bell

• 

  Michael Douglas

  Michael Douglas

  as

  Hosea Matthews

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  11 Vote Yes

  17 Vote No

  

  Hosea Matthews