Browse Casting Suggestions by framefreak on myCast - Fan Casting Your Favorite Stories

Recent fan casting activity by framefreak

Andy Serkis

Andy Serkis

as

The Whisperer (Voice inside the wall, never fully seen, always present)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Giancarlo Esposito

Giancarlo Esposito

as

Mr. Gray (Insurance agent who knows too much about the Harper family)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Anya Taylor-Joy

Anya Taylor-Joy

as

The Bleeding Woman (Figure seen by Jacob’s classmates in mirrors)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Javier Botet

Javier Botet

as

The Caretaker (Faceless entity in Abigail’s dreams)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Doug Jones

Doug Jones

as

Mr. Holloway (Man who speaks backwards in the woods)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Sarah Paulson

Sarah Paulson

as

Child Therapist Voss (Works with other children disturbed by Jacob’s presence)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Scoot McNairy

Scoot McNairy

as

Orderly Nash (Missing attendant after night shift with Jacob — who is also the sheriff.)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Jessie Buckley

Jessie Buckley

as

Nurse Hannah Greaves (Mental health nurse who begins seeing things in her dreams)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
David Dastmalchian

David Dastmalchian

as

Dr. George Finley (State-assigned psychiatrist evaluating Jacob)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Tilda Swinton

Tilda Swinton

as

Dr. Lillian Ray (Family trauma specialist working with Abigail)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Rami Malek

Rami Malek

as

Forensics Analyst Wren (Analyst who finds no trace of fingerprints or dust on Jacob’s belongings)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Kerry Condon

Kerry Condon

as

Dispatcher “Shelly” (Voice on the phone who hears something else on the line)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as

Officer Dale Pruitt (Skeptical veteran who dismisses Abigail's fears)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Mahershala Ali

Mahershala Ali

as

Detective Marcus Byrne (Missing persons specialist from out of state)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Riley Keough

Riley Keough

as

Deputy Karen Holt (Young officer torn between logic and instinct)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Paul Dano

Paul Dano

as

Frankie Bell (Gas station clerk who saw the van years ago)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
CCH Pounder

CCH Pounder

as

Lily West (Retired nurse who claims to have treated someone like Jacob before)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Stephen Root

Stephen Root

as

Peter Goodwin (Local hardware store owner, afraid of basements since 1994)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Frances Conroy

Frances Conroy

as

Janet Lind (Librarian who hides a forbidden book about local disappearances)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
John Carroll Lynch

John Carroll Lynch

as

Pastor Elwood (Local priest who warns Abigail about the “Impostor Spirit”)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Jeremy Ray Taylor

Jeremy Ray Taylor

as

Dylan Clark (Eric, tech-savvy boy who uncovers strange images on Jacob’s new phone)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Brooklynn Prince

Brooklynn Prince

as

Zoe Wilkes (Naomi, Jacob's seatmate who hears him whisper in class)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Christian Convery

Christian Convery

as

Aaron Miller (Tyler, tough kid who bullies Jacob and regrets it)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Mckenna Grace

Mckenna Grace

as

Hailey Grant (Brooke, shy girl who senses Jacob’s presence isn't right)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Ty Simpkins

Ty Simpkins

as

Liam Kelly (Mason, class clown with a secret fear of Jacob)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Jacob Tremblay

Jacob Tremblay

as

The Other Jacob (seen in flashbacks / Utah footage)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Julian Hilliard

Julian Hilliard

as

Timmy (strange boy at Jacob’s new school)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Olwen Fouéré

Olwen Fouéré

as

Mrs. Helgen (Reclusive Neighbor With Knowledge Of The Occult)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Scoot McNairy

Scoot McNairy

as

Sheriff Roland Clay (Conflicted Town Sheriff)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Kaitlyn Dever

Kaitlyn Dever

as

Emily (Abigail’s childhood best friend)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Ben Mendelsohn

Ben Mendelsohn

as

Garrett (The Abductor With A Disturbing Past)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Ethan Hawke

Ethan Hawke

as

Tom Harper (The Father, Hopeful And Broken)

in

The One Who Came Back

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Toni Collette

Toni Collette

as

Margaret Harper (The Mother, Emotionally Fractured)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Noah Jupe

Noah Jupe

as

Jacob Harper (The Missing Brother)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back
Florence Pugh

Florence Pugh

as

Abigail Harper (Older Sister And Main Protagonist)

in

The One Who Came Back

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The One Who Came Back

Andy Serkis

The Whisperer (Voice inside the wall, never fully seen, always present)

The One Who Came Back

Giancarlo Esposito

Mr. Gray (Insurance agent who knows too much about the Harper family)

The One Who Came Back

Anya Taylor-Joy

The Bleeding Woman (Figure seen by Jacob’s classmates in mirrors)

The One Who Came Back

Javier Botet

The Caretaker (Faceless entity in Abigail’s dreams)

The One Who Came Back

Doug Jones

Mr. Holloway (Man who speaks backwards in the woods)

The One Who Came Back

Sarah Paulson

Child Therapist Voss (Works with other children disturbed by Jacob’s presence)

The One Who Came Back

Scoot McNairy

Orderly Nash (Missing attendant after night shift with Jacob — who is also the sheriff.)

The One Who Came Back

Jessie Buckley

Nurse Hannah Greaves (Mental health nurse who begins seeing things in her dreams)

The One Who Came Back

David Dastmalchian

Dr. George Finley (State-assigned psychiatrist evaluating Jacob)

The One Who Came Back

Tilda Swinton

Dr. Lillian Ray (Family trauma specialist working with Abigail)

The One Who Came Back

Rami Malek

Forensics Analyst Wren (Analyst who finds no trace of fingerprints or dust on Jacob’s belongings)

The One Who Came Back

Kerry Condon

Dispatcher “Shelly” (Voice on the phone who hears something else on the line)

The One Who Came Back

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Officer Dale Pruitt (Skeptical veteran who dismisses Abigail's fears)

The One Who Came Back

Mahershala Ali

Detective Marcus Byrne (Missing persons specialist from out of state)

The One Who Came Back

Riley Keough

Deputy Karen Holt (Young officer torn between logic and instinct)

The One Who Came Back

Paul Dano

Frankie Bell (Gas station clerk who saw the van years ago)

The One Who Came Back

CCH Pounder

Lily West (Retired nurse who claims to have treated someone like Jacob before)

The One Who Came Back

Stephen Root

Peter Goodwin (Local hardware store owner, afraid of basements since 1994)

The One Who Came Back

Frances Conroy

Janet Lind (Librarian who hides a forbidden book about local disappearances)

The One Who Came Back

John Carroll Lynch

Pastor Elwood (Local priest who warns Abigail about the “Impostor Spirit”)

The One Who Came Back

Jeremy Ray Taylor

Dylan Clark (Eric, tech-savvy boy who uncovers strange images on Jacob’s new phone)

The One Who Came Back

Brooklynn Prince

Zoe Wilkes (Naomi, Jacob's seatmate who hears him whisper in class)

The One Who Came Back

Christian Convery

Aaron Miller (Tyler, tough kid who bullies Jacob and regrets it)

The One Who Came Back

Mckenna Grace

Hailey Grant (Brooke, shy girl who senses Jacob’s presence isn't right)

The One Who Came Back

Ty Simpkins

Liam Kelly (Mason, class clown with a secret fear of Jacob)

The One Who Came Back

Jacob Tremblay

The Other Jacob (seen in flashbacks / Utah footage)

The One Who Came Back

Julian Hilliard

Timmy (strange boy at Jacob’s new school)