Casting Suggestions by beleg

• 

  Jim Caviezel

  Jim Caviezel

  as

  Cirdan

  in

  The Silmarillion

  11 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Cirdan

• 

  Nicholas Hoult

  Nicholas Hoult

  as

  Beleg

  in

  The Silmarillion

  6 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Beleg

• 

  Olivia Wilde

  Olivia Wilde

  as

  Luthien

  in

  The Silmarillion

  9 Vote Yes

  18 Vote No

  

  Luthien

• 

  Wes Bentley

  Wes Bentley

  as

  Feanor

  in

  The Silmarillion

  7 Vote Yes

  15 Vote No

  

  Feanor

• 

  Christian Bale

  Christian Bale

  as

  Fingolfin

  in

  The Silmarillion

  5 Vote Yes

  6 Vote No

  

  Fingolfin

• 

  Chris Pine

  Chris Pine

  as

  Beren

  in

  The Silmarillion

  9 Vote Yes

  15 Vote No

  

  Beren

• 

  James McAvoy

  James McAvoy

  as

  Finrod

  in

  The Silmarillion

  4 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Finrod

• 

  Alexander Skarsgård

  Alexander Skarsgård

  as

  Tuor

  in

  The Silmarillion

  9 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Tuor

• 

  Joe Manganiello

  Joe Manganiello

  as

  Turin

  in

  The Silmarillion

  3 Vote Yes

  12 Vote No

  

  Turin

• 

  Gary Oldman

  Gary Oldman

  as

  Sauron

  in

  The Silmarillion

  4 Vote Yes

  14 Vote No

  

  Sauron