Casting Suggestions by jmrosenberger

• 

  Aaron O'Connell

  Aaron O'Connell

  as

  Arthur Morgan

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Arthur Morgan

• 

  David James Elliott

  David James Elliott

  as

  Drew MacFarlane

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Alexander Ludwig

  Alexander Ludwig

  as

  Micah Bell

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Micah Bell

• 

  Stephen Amell

  Stephen Amell

  as

  Arthur Morgan

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Arthur Morgan

• 

  Wilmer Valderrama

  Wilmer Valderrama

  as

  Abraham Reyes

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Laura Prepon

  Laura Prepon

  as

  Sadie Adler

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Ashley Aufderheide

  Ashley Aufderheide

  as

  Tilly Jackson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Callie Haverda

  Callie Haverda

  as

  Mary-Beth Gaskins

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Topher Grace

  Topher Grace

  as

  Sheriff Gray

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Topher Grace

  Topher Grace

  as

  Thomas Downes

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Topher Grace

  Topher Grace

  as

  Josiah Trelawney

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Michael Shannon

  Michael Shannon

  as

  Andrew Milton

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Michael Shannon

  Michael Shannon

  as

  Edgar Ross

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Michael Shannon

  Michael Shannon

  as

  Bill Williamson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Red Dead Redemption

• 

  Tobey Maguire

  Tobey Maguire

  as

  Micah Bell

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Micah Bell

• 

  Bill Hader

  Bill Hader

  as

  Dutch Van der Linde

  in

  Red Dead Redemption

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Dutch Van der Linde