Casting Suggestions by andrewhigdon

• 

  Emmy Rossum

  Emmy Rossum

  as

  Sadie Adler

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  2 Vote Yes

  5 Vote No

  

  Sadie Adler

• 

  Luke Grimes

  Luke Grimes

  as

  John Marston

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  16 Vote Yes

  15 Vote No

  

  John Marston

• 

  Cole Hauser

  Cole Hauser

  as

  Bill Williamson

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  8 Vote Yes

  6 Vote No

  

  Bill Williamson

• 

  Bert Kreischer

  Bert Kreischer

  as

  Insest Brother

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  6 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Insest Brother

• 

  Adrianne Palicki

  Adrianne Palicki

  as

  Abigail Roberts

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  4 Vote Yes

  8 Vote No

  

  Abigail Roberts

• 

  Russell Brand

  Russell Brand

  as

  Josiah Trelawny

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  2 Vote Yes

  11 Vote No

  

  Josiah Trelawny

• 

  Adrianne Palicki

  Adrianne Palicki

  as

  Sadie Adler

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  6 Vote Yes

  14 Vote No

  

  Sadie Adler

• 

  James Landry Hébert

  James Landry Hébert

  as

  Micah Bell

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  1 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Micah Bell

• 

  Karen Gillan

  Karen Gillan

  as

  Aloy

  in

  Horizon Zero Dawn (LAM)

  3 Vote Yes

  8 Vote No

  

  Aloy

• 

  Lily James

  Lily James

  as

  Aloy

  in

  Horizon Zero Dawn (LAM)

  2 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Aloy

• 

  Alba Baptista

  Alba Baptista

  as

  Aloy

  in

  Horizon Zero Dawn (LAM)

  9 Vote Yes

  7 Vote No

  

  Aloy

• 

  Lauren Cohan

  Lauren Cohan

  as

  Abigail Roberts

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  134 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Abigail Roberts

• 

  Michael Shannon

  Michael Shannon

  as

  Colm O'Driscoll

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  20 Vote Yes

  5 Vote No

  

  Colm O'Driscoll

• 

  Gary Oldman

  Gary Oldman

  as

  Colm O'Driscoll

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  33 Vote Yes

  8 Vote No

  

  Colm O'Driscoll

• 

  Willem Dafoe

  Willem Dafoe

  as

  Colm O'Driscoll

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  12 Vote Yes

  10 Vote No

  

  Colm O'Driscoll

• 

  Stephan James

  Stephan James

  as

  Lenny Summers

  in

  Red Dead Redemption 2

  5 Vote Yes

  9 Vote No

  

  Lenny Summers