Casting Suggestions by ungandul

• 

  Rachel McAdams

  Rachel McAdams

  as

  Erin

  in

  Mistakes Were Made

  6 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Erin

• 

  Grace Van Dien

  Grace Van Dien

  as

  Elle Jones

  in

  Written in the Stars Series

  3 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Elle Jones

• 

  AnnaSophia Robb

  AnnaSophia Robb

  as

  Elle Jones

  in

  Count Your Lucky Stars

  2 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Count Your Lucky Stars

• 

  Luca Hollestelle

  Luca Hollestelle

  as

  Darcy Lowell

  in

  Count Your Lucky Stars

  1 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Count Your Lucky Stars

• 

  Elizabeth Lail

  Elizabeth Lail

  as

  Elle Jones

  in

  Count Your Lucky Stars

  2 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Count Your Lucky Stars

• 

  Melissa Benoist

  Melissa Benoist

  as

  Olivia Grant

  in

  Count Your Lucky Stars

  6 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Count Your Lucky Stars

• 

  Aubrey Plaza

  Aubrey Plaza

  as

  Margot Cooper

  in

  Count Your Lucky Stars

  4 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Count Your Lucky Stars

• 

  Emma Watson

  Emma Watson

  as

  Charlotte Thompson

  in

  Those Who Wait

  1 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Charlotte Thompson

• 

  Ben Barnes

  Ben Barnes

  as

  William Thompson

  in

  Those Who Wait

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Those Who Wait

• 

  Anya Taylor-Joy

  Anya Taylor-Joy

  as

  Celia St. James

  in

  The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

  2 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

• 

  Eddie Redmayne

  Eddie Redmayne

  as

  Brandon Lowell

  in

  Written in the stars

  2 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Written in the stars

• 

  Amy Adams

  Amy Adams

  as

  Katherine Spencer

  in

  Those Who Wait

  1 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Those Who Wait

• 

  Dermot Mulroney

  Dermot Mulroney

  as

  Jack Spencer

  in

  Those Who Wait

  3 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Those Who Wait

• 

  Elizabeth Lail

  Elizabeth Lail

  as

  Elle Jones

  in

  Written in the Stars Series

  2 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Elle Jones

• 

  Lili Reinhart

  Lili Reinhart

  as

  Elle Jones

  in

  Written in the Stars Series

  2 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Elle Jones

• 

  Melissa Benoist

  Melissa Benoist

  as

  Olivia Grant

  in

  Written in the Stars Series

  3 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Olivia Grant