Casting Suggestions by wazifaabbubaker

• 

  Margot Robbie

  Margot Robbie

  as

  Toby's Mother

  in

  Ticci Toby.

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Ticci Toby.

• 

  Chris Evans

  Chris Evans

  as

  Toby's Father

  in

  Ticci Toby.

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Ticci Toby.

• 

  Melissa Benoist

  Melissa Benoist

  as

  Lyra Rogers

  in

  Ticci Toby.

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Ticci Toby.

• 

  Lucas Till

  Lucas Till

  as

  Toby Erin Rogers (Ticci Toby)

  in

  Ticci Toby.

  1 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Ticci Toby.

• 

  Black Cat

  Black Cat

  as

  Grinny Cat

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  2 Vote Yes

  0 Vote No

  

  Creepypastas Characters.

• 

  Tim Sutton

  Tim Sutton

  as

  Masky

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  6 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Creepypastas Characters.

• 

  Elizabeth Olsen

  Elizabeth Olsen

  as

  Judge Angels

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  1 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Judge Angels

• 

  Zendaya

  Zendaya

  as

  Kate The Proxy

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  1 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Creepypastas Characters.

• 

  Elizabeth Olsen

  Elizabeth Olsen

  as

  The Nurse Ann

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  5 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  The Nurse Ann

• 

  Scarlett Johansson

  Scarlett Johansson

  as

  The Nurse Ann

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  4 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  The Nurse Ann

• 

  Brian Haight

  Brian Haight

  as

  Hoddie

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  6 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Creepypastas Characters.

• 

  Tom Holland

  Tom Holland

  as

  X-Virus

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  1 Vote Yes

  1 Vote No

  

  Creepypastas Characters.

• 

  Tom Holland

  Tom Holland

  as

  Splendorman

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  2 Vote Yes

  4 Vote No

  

  Splendorman

• 

  Husky

  Husky

  as

  Smile Dog

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  12 Vote Yes

  2 Vote No

  

  Smile Dog

• 

  Evan Peters

  Evan Peters

  as

  Ben Drowned

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  8 Vote Yes

  5 Vote No

  

  Ben Drowned

• 

  Lucas Till

  Lucas Till

  as

  Toby Erin Rogers (Ticci Toby)

  in

  Creepypastas Characters.

  6 Vote Yes

  9 Vote No

  

  Toby Erin Rogers